Court Rules in Our Favor on 19 Facade MCIs

Based on objections our attorneys Collins Dobkin & Miller LLP filed via Article 78s, 7 facade MCIs were annulled outright and 12 were sent back to DHCR (Order and Decision). We prevailed on two key issues—failure of the owner to file applications within DHCR's own established deadlines and failure to meet IRS requirements for depreciability. Tenants in affected buildings, below, will get back money collected for these MCIs.

The 7 annulled MCIs include

EU410047RT (2 PCR); EU410048RT (431 East 20 St); FS410011RT (1, 3 Stuyvesant Oval);

FX410022RT (315, 319, 321 Ave. C); GN410045RT (6, 8, 10 Stuyvesant Oval);

GN410046RT (610, 620 East 20th St); GN410057RT (505, 515 East 14th St)

The 12 remanded MCIs include:

EU410046RT (541 East 20 St); EU410054RT (441 East 20 St); FS410034RT (390 First Ave);

FV410011RT (6 PCR); FV410038RT (7 PCR); GM410050RT (8 PCR);

GN410043RT (531 East 20 St); GN410044RT (271 Ave C) GN410047RT (530 East 23 St);

GR410031RT (5 P PCR); GR410032RT (510 East 23 St; GS410048RT (511 East 20 St) 

https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/ViewDocument?docIndex=KqEiYpwvwADIqu3iw8hr8g

Posted 1/7/23